New York’s New Tipping Rules: Are You Shortchanging Your Servers?
If you’re dining out this holiday season in New York, you should know that tipping expectations have changed. Tipping has always been a hot topic, especially with almost every transaction now asking for a gratuity.
While debates continue about whether tipping should be required, one thing remains clear: restaurant servers depend on tips to make a living.
Some might argue that tipping should be banned or that customers shouldn’t have to pay workers’ salaries. While that’s a discussion for the future, the current reality is different. Restaurant workers in the Hudson Valley can earn as little as $10 an hour. Until laws change, tipping is not just expected—it’s essential.
What Are the Current Tipping Rules in New York?
In New York State, restaurant workers get a minimum of $10 an hour as cash wages, with a $5 “tip credit.” This means employers count $5 from expected tips to meet the $15 hourly minimum wage.
In places like New York City, Long Island, and Westchester, servers receive a slightly higher amount—65 cents more per hour.
Many people don’t realize just how little servers are paid. When you understand their earnings, it’s hard not to think twice before skipping or leaving a low tip.
Tipping Guidelines Have Changed
You may have learned that 15% is a good tip, but times have changed. In 2024, even a 20% tip is considered the bare minimum by many servers and etiquette experts.
Here’s the new standard:
- Leave at least 20% for good service.
- If you’re paying a small bill, avoid tipping just a couple of dollars—tip more generously.
How Much Should You Tip in New York?
Most servers now expect tips between 20% and 25%. Anything below 20% is often seen as disrespectful, especially when workers are earning only $10 an hour. A 15% tip, once considered reasonable, is now viewed as outdated and insufficient.
Etiquette experts also recommend avoiding calculators when tipping. Calculating tips to the exact cent might come off as rude. Instead, round up to the nearest five or ten rupees. It’s a simple way to show appreciation without appearing stingy.
If You Dislike Tipping, Take It Up With Authorities
If you feel tipping is unfair, your complaints should be directed at lawmakers and business owners. Skimping on tips doesn’t change the system; it only hurts workers who rely on them. Until the tipping system changes, it’s a part of dining out in New York.
Why Does Your Tip Matters?
Adding an extra few dollars to your tip may feel unnecessary, but for workers, it’s crucial. That small amount can help them pay bills, support families, and meet basic needs. As customers, a generous tip can make a big difference in someone’s life without significantly affecting our wallets.
Note- Every piece of content is rigorously reviewed by our team of experienced writers and editors to ensure its accuracy. Our writers use credible sources and adhere to strict fact-checking protocols to verify all claims and data before publication. If any error is identified we promptly correct it and strive for transparency in all updates.