Witness Describes Deadly Subway Chokehold Incident in 911 Call Played at Trial

A dramatic 911 call played during the trial of the man accused of killing Jordan Neely, a homeless man, on a New York City subway in May, provided new details about the deadly encounter.

The call, made by a witness, described how Neely was allegedly “trying to attack everybody” before he was restrained by Daniel Penny, a former Marine. Penny is charged with manslaughter after Neely, who was unarmed, died following a chokehold administered by Penny during a struggle.

In the recording, the caller explains that Neely was allegedly behaving erratically on the train, claiming he was “out of control” and shouting at passengers.

The witness added that Neely had reportedly threatened others and acted aggressively, which prompted Penny to intervene. The 911 dispatcher asked for more details as the situation escalated, and the caller continued to describe Neely’s actions, suggesting the situation was growing tense and dangerous for those aboard the train.

The trial, which has sparked widespread debate about issues of self-defense, homelessness, and policing in New York City, centers on whether Penny’s actions were justified under the circumstances or if they were excessive.

The incident, which occurred in a packed subway car, was captured on video, with many witnessing Neely’s struggle and the subsequent fatal chokehold.

For more detailed coverage on the trial and 911 call, visit New York Post.