Discover 11 Tasty Reasons Utica Is an Upstate NY Foodie’s Dream City!
Utica, New York — a vibrant town in Central New York — stands out as a culinary destination that food enthusiasts should not miss. With its rich history, multicultural influence, and a diverse range of eateries, Utica offers an impressive selection of dining experiences that keep visitors coming back for more.
Utica’s food scene is a blend of traditional flavors, long-standing establishments, and innovative dishes that reflect the city’s cultural melting pot. Here are 11 standout reasons why Utica is recognized as one of Upstate New York’s premier food cities.
1. Delmonico’s Italian Steakhouse
Known for its generous portions and inviting ambiance, Delmonico’s Italian Steakhouse serves up hearty dishes that have become local legends.
A must-try here is the Delmonico Steak — a massive 24-ounce Angus beef rib-eye, perfectly seasoned and seared to satisfaction.
Location: 147 N. Genesee Street, Utica, NY
Menu Highlight: Delmonico Steak paired with Penne Marinara
Phone: (315) 732-2300
2. Swifty’s Restaurant and Pub
Swifty’s combines the lively atmosphere of a pub with a diverse menu of classic American fare. The restaurant’s friendly service and extensive options — from burgers to quesadillas — make it a hit for locals and tourists alike.
Location: 257 Genesee Street, Utica, NY
Menu Highlight: Cowboy Burger, topped with smoked bacon, BBQ sauce, and beer-battered onion rings
Phone: (315) 733-6611
3. Tailor and the Cook
This farm-to-table restaurant has garnered awards for its quality and dedication to locally sourced ingredients. Tailor and the Cook pays homage to Utica’s history and culinary roots, serving popular local dishes like Chicken Riggies.
Location: 311 Main Street, Utica, NY
Menu Highlight: Chicken Riggies, a signature Utica dish
Phone: (315) 624-3663
4. Sheri’s Eastside Diner
A favorite spot for a classic American breakfast, Sheri’s Eastside Diner delivers large portions of breakfast staples and an assortment of lunch options that keep customers full and satisfied.
Location: 2199 Bleecker Street, Utica, NY
Menu Highlight: “Gut-Buster” breakfast with six eggs, sausage, gravy, and toast
Phone: (315) 790-5250
5. Florentine Pastry Shop
For nearly a century, Florentine Pastry Shop has been delighting customers with its authentic Italian pastries. Known for its pasties (pastaciotti), these handheld pies come in various flavors and have become a Utica staple.
Location: 667 Bleecker Street, Utica, NY
Menu Highlight: Pusties, small pies with rich fillings
Phone: (315) 724-8052
6. Hapanowicz Brothers Meat Market
A local Polish gem, Hapanowicz Brothers Meat Market offers an array of meats and ready-to-eat meals. From sausages to mushroom stew, this market’s offerings allow visitors to taste Utica home.
Location: 19 Clinton Street, New York Mills, NY
Phone: (315) 736-8288
7. Celtic Harp Restaurant and Pub
Celtic Harp brings the spirit of Ireland to Utica with its extensive Irish-inspired menu. From hearty Guinness Beef Stew to Jameson BBQ Pulled Pork, this pub’s ambiance and fare create an unforgettable experience.
Location: 805 Varick Street, Utica, NY
Menu Highlight: Bangers and Mash, Shepherd’s Pie, Guinness Beef Stew
Phone: (315) 797-4277
8. Chowder House
This beloved seafood restaurant consistently delivers fresh dishes, such as clam chowder and mussel pasta. Chowder House is perfect for those looking for quality seafood in a cozy setting.
Location: 57 Burrstone Road, New York Mills, NY
Menu Highlight: Clam Chowder, Penne Pasta with Mussels
Phone: (315) 736-5840
9. O’Scugnizzo Pizzeria
O’Scugnizzo, America’s second-oldest pizzeria, remains iconic for its unique “upside-down” pizza. With over a century of history, this pizzeria continues to attract food lovers looking for a slice of Utica’s best.
Location: 614 Bleecker Street, Utica, NY
Menu Highlight: “Upstate Down” pizza with cheese on the bottom
Phone: (315) 6149
10. Killabrew Saloon
Famed for its wings and relaxed atmosphere, Killabrew Saloon offers flavors ranging from mild to adventurous, such as Mango Habanero and Brown Sugar Bourbon wings. It’s the ideal place for a casual night out with friends.
Location: 10 Clinton Road, New Hartford, NY
Menu Highlight: Brown Sugar Bourbon wings
Phone: (315) 732-9733
11. Chesterfield’s Tavolo
A top-tier Italian dining spot, Chesterfield’s Tavolo serves high-quality dishes inspired by local favorites. Their Chicken Riggies with “the original recipe” and unique Pasta Purses have won over countless diners.
Location: 131 N. Genesee Street, Utica, NY
Menu Highlight: Chicken Riggies, Pasta Purses stuffed with prosciutto and peas
Phone: (315) 732-9356
Utica’s culinary landscape is as diverse as it is rich in tradition. Whether you’re craving a classic steak, a pastry that melts in your mouth, or a taste of Italy with a Utica twist, this city has it all.
It’s no surprise that Utica has secured its place as one of the best food cities in Upstate New York, with each restaurant offering a slice of the city’s unique flavor.